Like almost everyone else I know, I am devastated by the results of this election. None of us believed it would go this way, so I understand why everyone is shocked. But what discourages me even more than my candidate losing is some of the hateful responses I am seeing on my Facebook feed. Everyone is lamenting that our fellow Americans are so much more racist and sexist and stupid and [insert insult here] than we thought they were.
I would like to suggest a different viewpoint. Consider that we live in a world where we don't trust our mainstream media, so we turn to social media and alternative news sources as our window to the outside world. But remember that our Facebook feeds and Google results are filtered to show us everything that we already believe. And alternative news sources are unabashedly biased, which is fine since they aren't trying to hide it, but we understandably choose the ones we already agree with and that doesn't exactly provide a new perspective.
The liberals and progressives and conservatives and the alt-right -- we all live in our own respective echo chambers. Hillary Clinton accused Trump of living in his own reality, and maybe that was just meant to be a jab, but it's painfully true. He created an alternative reality and took half of America with him. And those of us on the liberal side don't understand it because we simply don't experience it. We are not exposed to the rhetoric they hear all day, every day. Sure, we get soundbites of Trump's hateful language and play them on a loop, but that is all he is to us. Do you think the media spread by the alt-right focuses on those moments? I highly doubt that. Just as our media doesn't focus on all the moments where Hillary was caught flip-flopping or lying or anything else that goes with being the establishment politician that Trump supporters hate.
You might say that their sins are not comparable, but that is a matter of priorities and of presentation. I'm with those that hold civil rights above all, so I am willing to compartmentalize and overlook Hillary's greasiness as a politician. But I would like to make the argument that most Americans who voted for Trump did not do so because they are racist and sexist. In their world, those aspects of his message were played down. They voted for him for many of the same reasons that I supported Bernie in the primary: they are sick of the establishment and see him as a leader who will tear down or at least subvert the current system. They think that a Trump presidency will bring them more jobs and ultimately a better quality of life. Unfortunately they are most likely wrong about that.
As for his hatefulness? I think some of Trump's supporters got carried away with it, but many of them just saw it and preferred to look away. Not because they agree, but because they are too burdened with their own problems and with the incredible fear that has been instilled in them. They would rather focus on the positives that Trump has promised. Yes, it is a selfish choice, but those are the choices we tend to make when we are struggling. It's much easier to fight for the rights of other people when you are living in a diverse environment and have a steady income. That is not the case for many Trump supporters, especially in rural America.
I'm obviously not saying that I support or even condone this choice. I believe that we have made a huge mistake as a nation, and we have a lot of work to do. I'm just saying it was a choice made out of fear but also, believe-it-or-not, hope. It did not come from evil. Nothing good will come from hating our fellow Americans. The problem is that we've forgotten how to listen to each other. We can only breach this divide with compassion and respect.
I would like to suggest a different viewpoint. Consider that we live in a world where we don't trust our mainstream media, so we turn to social media and alternative news sources as our window to the outside world. But remember that our Facebook feeds and Google results are filtered to show us everything that we already believe. And alternative news sources are unabashedly biased, which is fine since they aren't trying to hide it, but we understandably choose the ones we already agree with and that doesn't exactly provide a new perspective.
The liberals and progressives and conservatives and the alt-right -- we all live in our own respective echo chambers. Hillary Clinton accused Trump of living in his own reality, and maybe that was just meant to be a jab, but it's painfully true. He created an alternative reality and took half of America with him. And those of us on the liberal side don't understand it because we simply don't experience it. We are not exposed to the rhetoric they hear all day, every day. Sure, we get soundbites of Trump's hateful language and play them on a loop, but that is all he is to us. Do you think the media spread by the alt-right focuses on those moments? I highly doubt that. Just as our media doesn't focus on all the moments where Hillary was caught flip-flopping or lying or anything else that goes with being the establishment politician that Trump supporters hate.
You might say that their sins are not comparable, but that is a matter of priorities and of presentation. I'm with those that hold civil rights above all, so I am willing to compartmentalize and overlook Hillary's greasiness as a politician. But I would like to make the argument that most Americans who voted for Trump did not do so because they are racist and sexist. In their world, those aspects of his message were played down. They voted for him for many of the same reasons that I supported Bernie in the primary: they are sick of the establishment and see him as a leader who will tear down or at least subvert the current system. They think that a Trump presidency will bring them more jobs and ultimately a better quality of life. Unfortunately they are most likely wrong about that.
As for his hatefulness? I think some of Trump's supporters got carried away with it, but many of them just saw it and preferred to look away. Not because they agree, but because they are too burdened with their own problems and with the incredible fear that has been instilled in them. They would rather focus on the positives that Trump has promised. Yes, it is a selfish choice, but those are the choices we tend to make when we are struggling. It's much easier to fight for the rights of other people when you are living in a diverse environment and have a steady income. That is not the case for many Trump supporters, especially in rural America.
I'm obviously not saying that I support or even condone this choice. I believe that we have made a huge mistake as a nation, and we have a lot of work to do. I'm just saying it was a choice made out of fear but also, believe-it-or-not, hope. It did not come from evil. Nothing good will come from hating our fellow Americans. The problem is that we've forgotten how to listen to each other. We can only breach this divide with compassion and respect.